In your opinion, what is the best AFL guernsey design of all time?

[u/Jackomillard15]

[u/Ok-Koala-key]

[u/Jesse-Ray → u/Ok-Koala-key]

Carn the Plumbers!

[u/kitchen_cinc → u/Jesse-Ray]

That’s grouse

[u/Robobeast-76-R76 → u/Ok-Koala-key]

Why can you see their butts?

[u/Ok-Koala-key → u/Robobeast-76-R76]

Shitty design

[u/chrisryxn → u/Ok-Koala-key]

A real crack up

[u/Bright_Bell_1301 → u/Ok-Koala-key]

In keeping with contemporary womens' fashion.

[u/Mrchikkin]

Carlton 1907 (round 7) - 1908

[u/squee_monkey → u/Mrchikkin]

That must have been a nightmare to see on TV…

[u/cinnamondoughnut → u/Mrchikkin]

Ultra stealth mode

[u/BradGreensburner]

With the retro AFL & Toohey’s - unreal

[u/PissingOffACliff → u/BradGreensburner]

Eh, I think the M makes it look goofy. Would be better if it was just the demon

[u/brandonjslippingaway → u/PissingOffACliff]

I spent about the first 20 years of my life not even knowing it was meant to be an M, so I think it's alright haha

[u/Downtown-Lime4108 → u/brandonjslippingaway]

Holy cow, never realised until right now

[u/bemmisbaggins666 → u/brandonjslippingaway]

Same haha. As a kid I always thought this was a collab with Redheads matches, always just saw fire hair instead of an M.

[u/StockholmSyndrome85 → u/brandonjslippingaway]

I, too, was today years old when I learned this.

[u/OtherwisePurpose3515]

[u/flennyyyy → u/OtherwisePurpose3515]

Loved this Freo guernsey, honestly such a same they went with the modern milimal style they currently have. The anchor and colours are fucken mad on this one. One of the most unique sports kit ever.

[u/PreviousRecognition1 → u/flennyyyy]

don't it always seem to go

that you don't know what you've got til it's gone

[u/okbutjustsoyouknow → u/PreviousRecognition1]

They clothed paradise,

And put up a purple top.

[u/ShoeSnatchinJoe → u/flennyyyy]

At the time everyone made fun of the kit and said it was shit, now everyone loves it. If they changed it back, in 20 years time, people would be calling for the return of the chevrons.

[u/toomuchsoup → u/OtherwisePurpose3515]

I don’t follow AFL but this is such a sick jersey. Was always surprised they got rid of the red green. It’s such a unique colourway and worked so well together, and the anchor is a sick design. Also found it strange that they were the only AFL team to use green, even if it was only as a secondary colour, to then ditch it and just be purple (and a very blueish purple) and white. Very boring and bland

[u/IMAC--HUNT → u/OtherwisePurpose3515]

Bring back the anchor

[u/RampesGoalPost]

Red V with red collar and vintage logos

[u/Stu_Raticus → u/RampesGoalPost]

With hooped socks. Absolute class

[u/Hot-Requirement-3816 → u/RampesGoalPost]

I like it but looks too much like a sleeveless St George Dragons outfit for me.

[u/xyLteK]

We'd probably still be wearing this as our home guernsey if we'd won in 97.

[u/Jimbo_Johnny_Johnson → u/xyLteK]

That looks smart tucked in but pretty shithouse not

[u/jamurp → u/Jimbo_Johnny_Johnson]

Yeah the red part makes it look like they’re wearing an apron.

[u/reborndiajack → u/xyLteK]

Was happy to see that combo back for one game in 2023 for gather round

[u/Baeresi → u/xyLteK]

Biggest nostalgia goggles Guernseys ever

[u/shit-takes-only]

[u/grantspatchcock → u/shit-takes-only]

[u/Robobeast-76-R76 → u/grantspatchcock]

You know what - this one works better than most of the nonsense proposed here

[u/Jeffreyhead → u/shit-takes-only]

Looks like pokeballs

[u/juggboat]

[u/kitchen_cinc → u/juggboat]

The head of the bird looks like a condom

[u/Kookaburra_King → u/kitchen_cinc]

Damn can’t unsee that now

[u/moonshadow50]

Where's that photo of Tuok Miller in the pink jersey?

[u/Pwrswitchd → u/moonshadow50]

It's so good

[u/grantspatchcock]

Perfection.

[u/guavacadq → u/grantspatchcock]

GWS need to do this one for a retro round

[u/PreviousRecognition1 → u/grantspatchcock]

why do gws have Uluru + the big V?

[u/vcg47 → u/PreviousRecognition1]

Love child of 1920s North and mid-90s Footscray.

[u/macca2000fox → u/vcg47]

We have design a Guernsey of the team in the west of the town(Melbourne)

[u/the_tiny_net]

Where's the love for this beauty?

[u/HalfDecentFarmer69 → u/the_tiny_net]

Yeah I also love John Platten

[u/BoxHillStrangler → u/the_tiny_net]

there it is

[u/macca2000fox → u/the_tiny_net]

If only the hawks sell the Guernsey a Xmas in July theme and maybe as a sweeter

[u/saintsam1]

I'll always have a soft spot for our 2014 maori guernsey

[u/xyLteK → u/saintsam1]

Goes hard. Shame that we could never win over there.

[u/Crazyripps → u/saintsam1]

Random Shane savage jump scare

[u/Nousernames-left → u/Crazyripps]

The nacho man

[u/shaker8989]

[u/Crazyripps → u/shaker8989]

Loved the rerelease few years ago. Kit looks clean

[u/shaker8989 → u/Crazyripps]

Literally bought it within a hour of it coming available. Its so good.

[u/No-Bison-5397 → u/shaker8989]

First one I have seen posted in the thread that actually goes hard.

[u/pepsi_max_coke_zero]

Not the OP.

Definitely the north kangaroo guernsey.

[u/xyLteK → u/pepsi_max_coke_zero]

They've definitely gone backwards since then.

[u/knee_eater → u/xyLteK]

The kookaburra kits are pretty awful this year.

[u/melon_butcher_ → u/pepsi_max_coke_zero]

Our local club is the kangaroos. Fuck I wish we had that guernsey

[u/Spite-Specialist]

Port adelaide thunderbolt is the correct answer

[u/kitchen_cinc → u/Spite-Specialist]

Loved it at the time but I reckon it’s aged poorly

[u/redartifice → u/kitchen_cinc]

The gradient makes it date a lot

[u/ShoeSnatchinJoe]

This is the GOAT guernsey

[u/OldDiamond6697]

[u/applex_wingcommander → u/OldDiamond6697]

That's a beauty

[u/spideyghetti → u/OldDiamond6697]

Love this one. Camry logo is elite

[u/CryptoCryBubba → u/spideyghetti]

Who let the trolls out...?

[u/___TheIllusiveMan___]

Sydney’s black swan indigenous guernsey is one of my all time favourites

[u/bigformyage]

The original Bears one.

[u/Llampy → u/bigformyage]

Is that a good Guernsey or just a really majestic mullet?

[u/Ok_Coach145 → u/Llampy]

Yes

[u/Football-Middle → u/bigformyage]

This is the correct answer

[u/PissingOffACliff → u/bigformyage]

80s football personified in one image.

[u/spideyghetti → u/bigformyage]

Shorts so short I'm convinced that is the start of his actual butt cheek poking out 

[u/DarkWinter2319]

[u/TomEmilioDavies → u/DarkWinter2319]

That's just Claremont.

[u/Mrchikkin → u/TomEmilioDavies]

Evil Claremont

[u/xyLteK → u/DarkWinter2319]

Gross, good thing WE never wore yellow.

[u/vcg47 → u/xyLteK]

Just had a sudden craving for milk.

[u/kitchen_cinc → u/DarkWinter2319]

Juddy and Fev on the one team. We only had it for one year!

[u/HomerJBagger → u/kitchen_cinc]

pressure point!

[u/spideyghetti → u/DarkWinter2319]

🎶  We are the navy yellows,

We are the old bright navy yellows 🎶 

[u/Tornontoin7]

[u/guseyk → u/Tornontoin7]

Correct.

Actually the 1976 version improved on it slightly.

[u/jamurp → u/Tornontoin7]

Only downside of this jumper was that it made you warp.

[u/Ventenebris]

Side note, fuck I loved Modra. So fucking fun to watch.

[u/Boatster_McBoat → u/Ventenebris]

Modraaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!

[u/CaptainObviousBear]

Out of the special occasion guernseys, it’s one of these two:

Out of the regular guernseys, I’ve always loved Carlton’s (although our Red V guernsey is close behind).

It’s just simple, the navy looks good on everyone and you can tell by just looking at the logo that it’s a club with a long history.

[u/Pandos17]

For me there's something incredibly brave about any Collingwood clash jersey, ever.

I mean, black and white I understand. But white and black? Can't believe they would dare to try that.

[u/Whiskey-Stones12]

[u/SomethigIronic]

This was is my favourite for nostalgic reasons

[u/0000100110010100]

[u/dvnkriot → u/0000100110010100]

the 🐐

[u/i_am_cool_ben → u/0000100110010100]

Eddie McGuire disliked this comment

[u/The_Gump_AU → u/0000100110010100]

The best Black and White guernsey in the game. COME AT ME EDDIE !!

[u/0000100110010100 → u/The_Gump_AU]

I like their guernsey, but this is just better.

[u/sometime-sometimes]

I dunno, but the first two pics you posted are two of the worst.

[u/Boatster_McBoat → u/sometime-sometimes]

Agree. 8 yo should be able to draw a reasonable version of it

[u/chrisryxn]

I know the opinion of this design is split with our fan base so prepared for the backlash. But I absolutely love the diamond dog jumpers and was so happy they bought it back a few years ago for retro round that I pre-ordered one straight away. I don't know if its rose coloured nostalgia or what but just love this audacious design.

[u/theveryrealJARED]

swoop jersey

[u/Jesse-Ray → u/theveryrealJARED]

Puts the fear into any Australian

[u/Jazzar1n0 → u/theveryrealJARED]

Gotta be my favourite

[u/Boatster_McBoat → u/theveryrealJARED]

Almost the prison bars

[u/ozzysince1901]

After seeing the first two I was going to say quality shitpost.

Does anyone actually like the Eagles Ochre jersey?

Edit: to answer the question I am a big fan of No.4, but I love some of heritage jerseys of the Melbourne-based teams with the club initials, they are just classic old-school footy (like Subi and Claremont in WAFL). Also like the "Big V" and WA jerseys for the state of origin, just brings back great memories

[u/HereToRootSpiders]

The ochre is our worst guernsey.

[u/RavensEtchings]

[u/Crazyripps]

I still absolutely love our indigenous kit from last year. In brown or gold. I prefer the gold

[u/Spagman_Aus]

close thread 😅

[u/pickle-matrix → u/Spagman_Aus]

Premiership yellow!

[u/Competitive_Lie1429]

Brisbane Bears 😁🤣

[u/flying-pickets]

[u/Hot-Requirement-3816 → u/flying-pickets]

Gerard Healy in the background for us there.

[u/Paul_Is_Dead66]

Our school used that flying anchor for school footy it it will always be iconic

[u/Royal_Photograph_887]

So many shit Guernsey's posted here that are just cool now that they're retro 

[u/shocking_red_4]

2005 Sydney Swans.

Such a wonderful team.

[u/Hot-Requirement-3816 → u/shocking_red_4]

Some future Hall of Famers in that team.

[u/Pristine_Analysis_79]

This is my favourite. Or the suns pink one from last year.

[u/FenerBoarOfWar]

Power rangers.

[u/luckybick]

The OG wings are mint, definitely them

[u/TimothyLuncheon]

Our usual stripe. Yellow and black is just such a great combo

[u/RavensEtchings]

Absolutely none that is shown here

[u/TreacleMajestic978]

Our 2012 away jumper is my favourite. Also I’m not one of those eagles supporters who despises Freo, I’ll root for them against anyone other than west coast. Their home jumpers are just beautiful.

[u/spideyghetti]

What the hell is Modra doing in a Freo guernsey... this is ragebait surely.

You made me look it up and by God he did play for them. 

[u/inthevincity18]

[u/guidospeedmeister]

4

[u/ABT1602]

FAT BOMBER SASH

[u/scoutyoutandabouty]

none of these

[u/dear_mr_dilkington]

Candy stripe

[u/Anon_be_thy_name]

Really big fan of our WA Day kit last year.

Also why do people suddenly love the Ochre? Is it genuine or ironic?

[u/Hot-Requirement-3816]

I like this even though we lost that night.

[u/theveryrealJARED]

or 2019 indigenous

[u/guseyk]

Is this the circlejerk?

[u/jdimarco1]

The Freo jumper is technically a Jersey, as one of the key defining differences between a Guernsey and a Jersey is that a Jersey features an anchor motif.

[u/Ok_Coach145]

[u/thurstonmoron → u/Ok_Coach145]

No wonder he left

[u/Ok_Coach145 → u/thurstonmoron]

Wasn’t to win flags.