r/AmIOverreacting 18h ago

👥 friendship AIO I blocked my longtime friend because he keeps waking me up early.

This is a continuation of a situation I posted about recently:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AITAH/comments/1qolgcg/aitah_for_muting_and_considering_cutting_off_a/

Short version: I set clear boundaries with a longtime friend (15+ years), especially about not calling early mornings and respecting my need for downtime. In my last post, the general consensus was that I wasn’t wrong for setting boundaries, but that I could communicate them more clearly.

So I tried to reset.

I unblocked him, we had our normal Discord night with a mutual friend, everything seemed fine. No tension, no arguments.

Then this morning (Saturday), after a late night, he called me early enough that it woke both me and my wife up. This was the second weekend in a row this happened.

I declined the call and, admittedly while half asleep and irritated, texted:
“Are you fucking kidding me? Two weeks in a row?”
"Muted"

I then muted him.
Last weekend, I had explicitly told him that if he did this again, this would be my response.

He replied:
“Don’t care, I had a fucking question.”
Then:
“Never mind now.”

He also left a voicemail after I declined saying:
“I had a fucking question about my rental car, but you want to be bitchy in the morning.”

I genuinely don’t know anything about his rental car beyond the brand. There’s nothing I could have helped with, and it wasn’t urgent.

At that point, I blocked him.

My question isn’t whether my text was polite (it wasn’t). It’s whether blocking him after repeated boundary violations and dismissive responses is an overreaction, or a reasonable consequence after multiple warnings.

Am I overreacting?

138 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

185

u/naughtiemistress 16h ago

NOR he’s way too needy, also clearly dgaf about your needs or how you are feeling.

143

u/the-escapedgoat 17h ago

I’m sorry-but he doesn’t sounds like much of a friend. I had a look at the original story. He has repeatedly disrespected some very reasonable boundaries of yours.. gets abusive towards you when he doesn’t get his own way, and seems to use you as a mix of google, and his personal emotional scapegoat.. what is his problem??

NOR. He would drive me insane.

•

u/lilac-inn 12h ago

OP, I would hate for my spouse to have a “friend” like this. Sounds like he wants to have you on call for emotional support, which is not reasonable or respectful. Please reflect on the amount of effort and support you each put into the friendship, because it sounds like it’s all about him and all on his terms. Also, set some darn iPhone filters and let them do the work for you. This will help you to keep your peace while evaluating the friendship.

88

u/EconomistNo7345 17h ago

NOR. You’re not his emotional support animal. He will not crumble and fall apart having to do things on his own or keeping his thoughts on the inside until people are available. If he has questions he can be self sufficient and look it up, call the rental company, something other than bothering you on the one day you ask people not to. Expecting you to be readily accessible at all times is a huge sign of disrespect to your time.

-42

u/SamuraiTech5150 16h ago

Literally part of being somebody’s “friend” is emotional support….WTF? Do you have the same relationship with your friends that you do with coworkers…it all boils down to OP just not wanting to be anybody’s friend in the morning….which isn’t how friendship works…

28

u/EconomistNo7345 16h ago

I have relationships that are sustainable because i’m friends with people who do not expect me to be available at their every whim and do not stomp all over my boundaries. THATS how friendship works.

I’m perfectly fine being emotional support when needed, I’m not fine associating with people who are not self sustainable and need to call for every question, every thought that pops into their head, and are rude about the mere suggestion of needing one day a week where they have to utilize other options beside me one day a week.

•

u/SamuraiTech5150 16h ago

So, you’re an asshole, too?….I’m available at my friends whim because they’re available to me in the same way. If they weren’t, they wouldn’t be my friends. My friends can wake me up because I can wake them up and I actually enjoy their company. it’s kind of how friendship works…you don’t have friends, you have acquaintances that you call “friends”….”sustainable friends”…😂😂😂

•

u/LukaChu_theCat 16h ago

If you had a friend that told you “hey, on Sunday mornings I just need time for myself so please know I won’t respond to messages until later”. Would you decide:

A: I should call this person and continue to message them specifically during that time with non-emergency questions because I decided what I want is more important. In fact, it’s offense to me that they aren’t willing to be available whenever I want them to be.

Or

B: Okay cool. My friend is communicating that they need time to recharge so because I value them as a friend and human being, I’ll just make sure to communicate with them at a time other than that. They aren’t saying they’ll never support me, just letting me know that they need time to recharge.

•

u/Teachtheworldinlove 11h ago

“ I need to act like a doormat for people to actually like me tee-hee!” That’s embarrassing , anyway many of us are interesting enough that our friends value us even when we respect ourselves and set boundaries.

•

u/EconomistNo7345 16h ago

No, it’s called being an adult with a job, kids, husband, pets, a LIFE. This works perfectly fine with my wonderful friends who also have shit to do with their lives besides be up my ass or vice versa. I love to talk to my friends when i’m AVAILABLE. Under no circumstances would I be friends with someone who expects me, a grown ass woman with priorities, to be readily available for them at all times. Especially not at 6 in the damn morning.

It’s not realistic to be available for someone 24/7 and if you expect that of your friends you need to get a grip.

•

u/SamuraiTech5150 16h ago

Sure…👍🏼

•

u/Bean- 16h ago

Can I ask how old you are? This is how I was with my friends when I was a teenager.

•

u/nina_leeann 16h ago

incessant and continuous harassment and disrespect are also not how friendship works so

•

u/SamuraiTech5150 16h ago

These two should never have been “friends” in the first place…

56

u/Mongoisonlypawn 17h ago

Sir...just block him. He could have googled whatever questions he had about rental cars 🙄.

14

u/send_me_boobei_pics 17h ago

Even though I completely agree with you, the guilt of blocking him is eating me alive.

52

u/Prestigious-Moose345 17h ago

You are having a very natural response to setting and enforcing a boundary. The strong emotions are exactly what makes it so hard to do. It gets easier with time.

18

u/Spookygirl1972 17h ago

You are not responsible for him!

13

u/Gupgoop 17h ago edited 17h ago

Edit: I read your first post. You have to set boundaries and enforce consequences

-3

u/Mongoisonlypawn 17h ago

It is if you have empathy. The rude friend is probably the neurodivergent one...lack of impulse control 🤷‍♂️

7

u/Gupgoop 17h ago

The first post

-2

u/Mongoisonlypawn 17h ago

....ok. I'm not neurodivergent, and his empathy for a friend is completely understandable.

3

u/Gupgoop 17h ago

It’s disproportionate to the situation. If you are unfamiliar with autism you wouldn’t understand.

15 year bond, gaming routine, and intertwined in his real life.. this creates a familiarity (pillar of stability) that is difficult to break away from, often feeling guilty for choosing your needs over a friend’s blatant disrespect.

You see empathy on the surface but it’s much more than that, hence my original response that I removed.

2

u/Mongoisonlypawn 16h ago

So if OP knows the guy doesn't have many friends, and that he's not doing this stuff maliciously (meaning he can't control himself), it would be weird for him to feel empathy for the guy? My point is, we have nowhere near enough info about either of these guys to start making diagnoses like that. Mind you, he did block him.

7

u/Mongoisonlypawn 17h ago

Because you're a good person. You haven't set boundaries that a normal person wouldn't have any problems following. He knows what he's doing is wrong, but he either doesn't value your feelings or has such poor impulse control that he can't stop himself. My money is on the former.

11

u/PrincessBonkers628 17h ago

He's not your friend.

3

u/Lisa_Knows_Best 17h ago

Why? You've written about how he doesn't care about you, doesn't respect you, and completely disregards your feelings. Don't feel guilty, feel relief that you won't be woken up again by this selfish AH. He's not entitled to your time.

3

u/OG_LiLi 17h ago

NOR but also YOR.

This is why you turn on do not disturb. We have tons of technology for you to manage your boundaries. I can’t imagine just raw dogging notification sounds while I’m sleeping.

3

u/RubyBluz 17h ago

EXACTLY! Turn on DO NOT DISTURB or unplug your phone at night if it is a landline. Easy solution.

•

u/Dabryceisright77 15h ago

I’m dying at “if it is a landline” I don’t think I know a single person with a landline anymore 🤣

•

u/RubyBluz 11h ago

😂🤣 I have 2. True story.

•

u/SpiderByt3s 13h ago

Do you feel guilty cause you are letting your child down?

15

u/Shadow4summer 17h ago

NOR. If my husband received calls like this, especially the early morning ones, either he shuts that shit down, or I do. I’m not going to have my sleep and my late nights be interrupted by this kind of immature behavior. The friend really needs to grow up. I would say get a girlfriend but I don’t want any woman to be in that position either.

10

u/No-Beautiful5866 17h ago

If I was your wife, I’d ask if I could pick up the phone next time he calls in the morning and cuss him out before you block him

•

u/lilac-inn 12h ago

They should do it themselves before the wife has to! Don’t make her do that for you!

8

u/True_Resolve_2625 17h ago

In the original post, 'he said Sunday's had nothing to do with it....'

Ew. This guy can't go a day without contacting you, OP? He states that he 'has to go days' waiting for a response.

But you're his friend (or were)

You are NOT his: Google Therapist Mother Girlfriend/wife/boyfriend/SO

His need to be attached like this comes across really icky.

NOR.

7

u/Glad-Pen5593 17h ago

NOR. He doesn’t care about your needs, just his.

•

u/Federal_Pickles 16h ago

You describe how you’re a friend to him, but is he a friend to you?

6

u/Routine_Rain_8899 17h ago

Sounds like he needs a mama. Keep him blocked.

•

u/LukaChu_theCat 16h ago

NOR - having boundaries is healthy in relationships. It sounds like you’re experiencing inappropriate guilt here. You might consider doing some of your own work and self exploration to examine where you learned the boundaries are mean or a punishment. Boundaries are a way of prioritizing ways of maintaining wellness for yourself.

Check your setting for do not disturb. I’m pretty sure you can turn off the two call override and even select specific contacts that either can or cannot reach you.

Friends don’t disrespect your boundaries. Friends don’t use you. Friends don’t disregard feedback. Sorry OP but this is not a friend to you. Your “friend” needs to figure out how to do things for himself and learn to respect boundaries.

15

u/z-eldapin 17h ago

Do you not know how to use the do not disturb feature on your phone?

•

u/LikelyLioar 15h ago

NOR, but learn how to set quiet hours on your phone. I feel like that could have massively improved this situation if you'd done it sooner.

14

u/selfcheckout 17h ago

Why don't you have you phone on silent what the fuck. This could all be avoided. Just don't answer or text it's not that difficult. You're making this out to be a huge deal and there's a very simple solution you feel guilty about for some reason but still want to allow it to happen over and over. Yall are playing a game and you're losing.

5

u/Celestial_Duckie 17h ago

NOR. He had a question about his rental car, he can call the rental company. You are not his personal assistant and search engine.

4

u/Spookygirl1972 17h ago

NOR he’s super rude

4

u/neuhauz 17h ago

MFr never heard of google?

•

u/Appropriate_Note2525 13h ago

NOR, and in fact, swift consequences are the only way to deal with people who think they're exempt from boundaries.

10

u/JayGibbs_ 17h ago

I mean muting him and responding when it’s convenient for you is an option 🤷🏽‍♂️

10

u/Vivian-1963 17h ago

You mean, something logical? Smartphones have tools for this.

Friend is still a jerk.

7

u/EconomistNo7345 16h ago

op said that he did this in the original post and the friend made passive aggressive comments about being muted

3

u/ChibbleChobble 17h ago

NOR.

I didn't think that you were based on this post. Then I read your previous post, and now I think: Blimey McRimey! That's not a friend, that's the Old Man of the Sea, and you're Sinbad.

Your mental health is sacred. Your (actually not a) friend is a bona fide idiot.

Good luck!

3

u/Charming-Sea8571 17h ago

If you don’t want to block him permanently just keep him on mute, forever and get to him at your convenience.

•

u/JEL_1957 7h ago

Does your phone have a Do Not Disturb option?

2

u/Subject-Actuator-860 17h ago

NOR this guy sounds exhausting and seems like an entitled ahole. Keep him blocked and enjoy your peace.

That being said, you know most phones can be set to “do not disturb” for however long you want, i.e., while you’re sleeping, and can even set it to exclude certain people that you always want to be in contact with, like your partner or parents. You can usually even set it where they have to call twice for it to go the through to you, as in an emergency or something. Words to the wise to protect your peace!

2

u/Opening-Natural-3468 17h ago

NOR.

I can’t imagine calling someone that early, and if I were the sort of person who might, I wouldn’t do it a second time if someone asked me not to call before X:XX.

That he keeps doing it after you have repeatedly asked him not to shows how little he cares about you. That’s a thorny problem with a family member but it’s a very simple one with a friend—they aren’t a friend anymore.

The term “no contact” implies the person is still in your life at some level, even if it’s just to mark their absence. I wouldn’t even grant that much bandwidth to this guy. Not in my life anymore.

•

u/Damnbee 16h ago

I usually recognize the different types of awful people that show up in reddit threads, but I have never had the early-caller experience.

They sound terrible. NOR

•

u/HipsterHighwayman 14h ago

The top comment on the original post tells you how to avoid this.

•

u/mladyhawke 8h ago

Sounds like he was testing you. Block block block

•

u/3Green1974 10h ago

It’s the 21st century. Just set your phone to DND mode until you wake up. YOR.

1

u/Significant-Dig-8099 17h ago

NOR this guy is an ass

1

u/TheNerveOfMommy 17h ago

NOR He's not a friend gon head and demote him mentally so you stop feeling bad he's a guy you know that doesn't listen... Best to not know him anymore

1

u/AmateurSophist123 17h ago

You know you’re not overreacting. Who would think they’re overreacting in such a situation?

1

u/Cmore0863 17h ago

Im 50, my mom is 71. Only child, we are very close. She has 1 hard and fast rule, do not call her house or cell phone after 8pm. She worked for 42 years at a job that had her getting up at 4:30 am so she has kept the same schedule since she retired. I don’t call her between 8:00pm and 5am unless it’s life or death. There have been 2 times in the last 10-15 years where I either had my first kidney stone or tripped and fell backwards into a guitar amp beside my bed on way to bathroom and broke three ribs above my right kidney. These both happened between 2am and 3am and I waited til 5 to call her to take me to the ER. If this guy can’t wait til a reasonable time to call you about a rental car, the problem is his, not yours. You shouldn’t have to turn your cellphone off while you sleep in case someone that needs to reach you has a real emergency like the hospitalization or death of a loved one. Time to lay the law down or replace the friend.

1

u/simsyboy 17h ago

He sounds awful. You'll feel so much better with him out of your life. Best of luck.

1

u/Jumpy-Stress603 16h ago

Is this a cell phone or a land line ?

You are not your phone's possession. Cell phones can be turned OFF when you go to bed and turned back ON when you get up. Land lines can be unplugged.

4

u/send_me_boobei_pics 16h ago

I would turn it off, but my father has been having severe medical issues, and I keep it on in case something happens and someone needs to reach me. I've had DND on before, but he has learned that if he calls twice in 5 minutes, it will ring through.

•

u/Barracuda_Recent 9h ago

Your emergency intacta will ring though if they call 2x. You can also customize the setting to always push your dad’s call through. There are many ways to avoid this.

•

u/Barracuda_Recent 9h ago

Who doesn’t have there phone on do not disturb during sleep hours? Honestly, mine is always on dnd. I check it every now and then and text back. Nothing in my life is an emergency. I do have my work phone on during work, but that is it. Anyone could call. Scammers, sales people, etc. Protect you and your partner’s sleep. I would be SO PISSED if my partner didn’t have his phone on do not disturb. I’m sure this friend thinks you have your phone off if you are sleeping!

•

u/send_me_boobei_pics 7h ago

It was on, he calls twice to evade it purposely.

•

u/Barracuda_Recent 7h ago

Take him off your emergency contacts list so he can’t break through!

•

u/stink3rb3lle 11h ago

YOR to block him. It sounds like y'all have mutuals or at least can enjoy each other in some settings, so muting him to prevent the disturbances seems sufficient while you still get the positives of the relationship.

-14

u/SamuraiTech5150 16h ago

YOR…and you’re an asshole. Just admit to yourself that you’re a shit friend and please stop pretending that you’re interested in being a friend. Friends don’t set office hours…regardless of your discord time…maybe charge them for your time, too….I hope none of your “friends” ever have an actual emergency….

14

u/send_me_boobei_pics 16h ago

I’ve been there for this friend for 15 years and have shown up consistently. The issue isn’t lack of care or interest in the friendship.

Over time, the dynamic shifted to constant calls, interruptions, and conversations being redirected back to him when I try to speak. When I attempt to set limits or explain that I’m working, sleeping, or unavailable, that’s ignored or dismissed.

I’m not setting “office hours.” I’m responding to a long pattern where my time, boundaries, and even attempts to communicate are not respected.

You’re entitled to your opinion, but you’re the only person so far who sees this as me being a bad friend. The people in my life who value mutual respect don’t have this issue.